Call or Text Us Today! (928) 753-6868

Legal News

The Problems with Citizen: a New Program Allowing the Public to Submit Videos to Police

Posted by Shawn B. Hamp | Jan 25, 2018 | 0 Comments

Taser, the company known for making the electrical shocking devices that nearly every police officer carries, has rebranded as a new company, Axon, and is developing a new law enforcement tool: a crowdsourced database of videos.

New Program Allows Members of the Public to Send Videos to Police

The program, which Axon calls “Citizen,” allows members of the public to upload videos they took of a possible crime to a database that's controlled by their local police force. In what has been described as a “Dropbox for cops,” Citizen creates an online portal that's accessible to anyone in the public. Once there, they can proactively upload videos that they took of a particular incident. Alternatively, police at the scene of an incident can urge people who took videos to go to the portal and upload it.

Citizen's pundits stress the fact that the program does not store the phone numbers of cell phones that upload videos, and that uploaders can choose to withhold contact information when they post content.

However, these safeguards are not entirely true and are only a part of the problem with the Citizen program.

Police Can Mine Data in Uploaded Videos

All of the content that gets uploaded into the Citizen database will contain metadata – information about the uploaded content. Importantly, this includes information about the device that took a specific video, which police can use to find the person who uploaded it, even if they tried doing it anonymously.

Perhaps worse, once a video has been uploaded and is in the Citizen database, police can cross-reference images in the video with other public information – like what you post on social media and Facebook. For example, they can use facial recognition software to try identifying people in a video submitted on Citizen, using Facebook account pictures. Because facial recognition software is still far from perfect, innocent people could find themselves suspects in incidents when they hundreds of miles away. This becomes especially disconcerting if Citizen is used by the public for meaningless “tips,” like reporting an annoying neighbor: These invasive videos could provide evidence for an unrelated offense.

Program Will Not Promote Police Accountability

In a way, Citizen will become similar to police body cameras. However, just like body cameras have not increased police accountability, videos uploaded to Citizen will not, either, because video from both sources are controlled by the police. In both cases, local police departments dictate who can see the video and how long they will keep it in their database – decisions that can effectively prevent any meaningful review of the videos to determine police overreach.

Shawn Hamp: Western Arizona's Criminal Defense Attorney

Law enforcement tools like Citizen are fraught with complexities that need to be resolved before becoming ubiquitous. Criminal defense attorney Shawn Hamp knows this, and vows to fight for the accused throughout western Arizona. Contact him online or call his law office at (866) 490-HAMP.

About the Author

Shawn B. Hamp

President and lead counsel for The Hamp Law Offices, LLC (An Arizona Professional Corporation), Shawn Hamp has practiced law for more than 15 years with an emphasis in criminal law. An experienced trial attorney, Mr. Hamp has been lead counsel in hundreds of criminal trials and court...


There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment

Contact Us Today

If you have been arrested or charged with a crime, you may be feeling frightened, anxious, and uncertain of what your future holds. The competent and experienced attorneys at the Hamp Law Offices can help you during this difficult time. We are dedicated to fighting for the rights of our clients and providing excellent legal representation to those who have been accused of a crime. Contact our firm today to discuss your case.