Call or Text Us Today! (928) 753-6868

Legal News

Two Huge Cases Being Heard by the U.S. Supreme Court

Posted by Shawn B. Hamp | Jan 03, 2018 | 0 Comments

When the Supreme Court of the United States makes a statement about the law, all of the courts in the country are bound by what it says, including those in Arizona. Now that there are finally nine Justices on the bench – making a 4-4 tie less likely – the Court is primed to hear some high-profile cases that can have a huge impact on America's future.

While the Court's decisions on gerrymandering and wedding cakes are bound to attract more attention, there are a handful of cases that will have a significant impact on the criminal defense world.

Here are two of them.

Carpenter v. U.S.

Your Fourth Amendment rights protect you from unreasonable searches. However, what you knowingly and voluntarily expose to the public does not require a “search” under the Fourth Amendment, allowing police to access any information that you give to someone else. This is the “third party doctrine,” and includes things like your trash, which you give to the trash collectors, and your phone records, which you give to your service provider.

The third-party doctrine, however, was created well before the internet. Since then, people have voluntarily given massive amounts of information to third parties, allowing police access to huge amounts of information that they can use to learn of your whereabouts, what you buy, and what you do online. Justice Sotomayor has voiced concern with how pervasive this information has become.

Carpenter v. U.S. is the first third-party doctrine case to make it to the Supreme Court since Sotomayor voiced her displeasure with the doctrine. We may see the Court finally take a stand for your Fourth Amendment rights and rein in the third party doctrine.

Class v. U.S.

It's a fact that nearly all criminal charges do not make it to trial. Instead, approximately 95% of the people charged with a crime end up taking a plea deal. By pleading guilty, you waive numerous rights you have to appeal. One of those rights is your ability to claim that the law you violated was unconstitutional.

Class v. U.S. tackles this problem head on. Rodney Class was arrested and ended up pleading guilty to a weapons charge. After pleading guilty, he wanted to challenge the constitutionality of the law that he'd been charged with, claiming it violated his rights under the Second Amendment.

Because of the huge numbers of criminal defendants who plead guilty rather than go to trial, many of the laws that they plead guilty to go unchallenged in court. Class gives the Supreme Court the opportunity to change that by allowing these defendants to challenge the law, despite taking a plea bargain.

Arizona Criminal Defense Attorney Shawn Hamp

These two cases can have a shocking impact on the criminal justice system and everyone's daily lives. Class can create useful dialogue on which of our laws abide by the constitution, while Carpenter can protect your personal information and privacy from the prying eyes of the police.

If you've been charged with a crime in Arizona, call the law office of criminal defense attorney Shawn Hamp at (866) 490-HAMP or contact him online.

About the Author

Shawn B. Hamp

President and lead counsel for The Hamp Law Offices, LLC (An Arizona Professional Corporation), Shawn Hamp has practiced law for more than 15 years with an emphasis in criminal law. An experienced trial attorney, Mr. Hamp has been lead counsel in hundreds of criminal trials and court...


There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment

Contact Us Today

If you have been arrested or charged with a crime, you may be feeling frightened, anxious, and uncertain of what your future holds. The competent and experienced attorneys at the Hamp Law Offices can help you during this difficult time. We are dedicated to fighting for the rights of our clients and providing excellent legal representation to those who have been accused of a crime. Contact our firm today to discuss your case.